June 20, 2013

What do you do with classroom observation data?

At their core, classroom observations should be about coaching, building up professional practice, and supporting better outcomes for students. Principals should use classroom observation data to enrich conversations during professional learning community meetings, individual teacher coaching conferences, and staff meetings. When large samples of student data are available, school leaders can disaggregate the data by age, content area, or other categories to enable powerful analysis of the data’s meaning and uses. This, combined with other evidence, can be used to support school improvement goals, collaborative planning, professional development planning, and a common understanding of what quality pedagogy looks like. Principals who do this well can help their teachers make great gains in teaching and learning.

We’re sometimes asked by principals and district leaders who are interested in Power Walkthrough® for more information about how the system ties in with research-informed instructional practices and good classroom observation protocols and purposes.

The Power Walkthrough system supports best practice by using a carefully designed template of observable elements based on the best understanding of modern pedagogy, with indicators of research-informed classroom environmental factors, instructional strategies, learning taxonomies, technology applications, evidence of learning, and student interview responses. The template is customizable, so that if a school wants to focus on formative assessment or collaborative learning, they can do so by adding or substituting observation elements. We recommend not adding too much to the observation template, so that it doesn’t turn into a teacher evaluation tool and take too long to conduct. If individual observations take more than 3-5 minutes to conduct, principals won’t be able to visit enough classrooms for the data to be valid and reliable.

Validity and reliability of data relies not only on a sufficient sample size, but also on the skill of the observer. Becoming an efficient, skilled, and astute observer of teaching and learning takes quality training, practice, and collaborative reflection between observers. School leaders don’t have to be experts in all content areas to conduct good observations, but they do have to be highly knowledgeable in pedagogy and be a keen observer of student learning evidence. The Power Walkthrough templates help principals by providing cues, “look-fors,” and a common nomenclature.

Templates and lists provide structure and allow for statistical analysis, but they don’t preclude the principal from observing other factors in the classroom, interviewing students, or recording descriptive notes. In fact, Power Walkthrough observations are designed to end with student interviews to gather student perspectives on what they’re trying to learn and why they’re learning it, to see if they fully comprehend the objectives of the lesson. Answers such as “we’re learning math because we have a test on Friday” aren’t good enough. A great answer would be something like, “we’re learning how to graph polynomials because they can be used to model how some things work in nature like the shape a stream of water takes when it’s shot out of a fountain or the path of a basketball when you shoot a free throw.”

In the end it’s not about the instrument itself, but how it’s applied. Depending on the goals of school leadership, Power Walkthrough can be used either for typical data collection purposes or innovative change. We encourage instructional leaders to collaborate with each other and their teachers to learn from the data together. Teachers will take ownership of the data’s meaning if they are allowed to find it themselves rather than using a top-down approach of dictating to them what the data means. If used regularly and collaboratively, Power Walkthrough data can provide a wealth of professional development experiences for all educators, both on a daily basis and as part of a whole school improvement effort.

We hope this explains a little more about how Power Walkthrough supports good classroom observation practices and instructional improvement. If there are other aspects of classroom observation protocols and use of data that you’d like us to address, we’d be happy to. Feel free to send me a direct e-mail, or use the comments box below.

DisplayThumbnailNoDB[1]Matt Kuhn is a principal consultant at McREL, where he designs and delivers professional development and provides technical assistance to school and districts in instructional technology, STEM, and leadership. You can reach him at mkuhn@mcrel.org or 303-632-5628.

 

 


 

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a010536aec25c970b0191039cffa6970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference What do you do with classroom observation data?:

Comments

As a teacher that is going to be observed with a power walkthrough this week, I find this blog to be very informative! You were able to clearly explain why there is a need for this. In the past when I was observed, I wasn't given any critical feedback. I seemed as if the observation was full of assumtions of what my classroom looked like based off of my personality. This type of observation gives a variety of snapshots that give a clear picture of who I am as a teacher. I believe that observations should give teachers coaching experiences. I am only in my second year of teaching, and really look for that advice in helping me improve as a teacher.

Patricia, feedback on informal walkthroughs is tricky. On the one hand, a small dollop of feedback helps teachers synchronize their thoughts on what occurred with their observer’s observations. But too much time spent on giving feedback on each little observation can lead to a situation in which not enough observations can be collected for the overall data to be meaningfully analyzed. Thus, the school leadership is unable to see the forest for the trees. Once enough observations have been collected, observers should meet with teachers to discuss deeper meaning now that patterns can be seen in the larger sample size.

I agree that the ultimate purpose of classroom observations should be teacher coaching. I believe I am an excellent teacher, but I also believe I have room for improvement; however, whenever I am observed, I am not given any feedback or coaching to help me become better. When I do improve in certain aresa that I see deficiencies, it is because I found a professional development opportunity that met that need. It would be nice if those trained observers were more helpful.


A concise and focused explanation of the purpose of Power Walkthrough. The bottom line...help teachers improve professional practice with the ultimate goal of increasing student achievement.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.